The drop is always movingYou know that saying about standing on the shoulders of giants? Drupal is standing on a huge pile of midgetsAll content management systems suck, Drupal just happens to suck less.Popular open source software is more secure than unpopular open source software, because insecure software becomes unpopular fast. [That doesn't happen for proprietary software.]Drupal makes sandwiches happen.There is a module for that

Doxygen standards

Submitted by nk on Tue, 2010-05-11 18:07

Please read the much evolved Doxygen standards. Common mistakes include forgetting a newline before @return, and function doc has to start with 3th person verb. Props to aspilicious for working tirelessly on fixing these errors and to jhodgdon our API documentation maintainer.

Put up or shut up

Submitted by nk on Sat, 2010-05-08 08:18

If you have not participated in core development then please do not write ill informed, baseless derisive blog posts and especially not to the Drupal Planet. Critique is good, baseless bashing just makes those who actually do the work feel depressed, angry and sad. I now abstain from reading the development list, the forums could we please keep at least the Planet a place which a developer can read without wanting to hit something? kthxbye

How to foster contribution?

Submitted by nk on Fri, 2010-04-30 19:38

I often lament that new Drupal community members are not like "old" and they are not contributing enough. But... do they have enough incentive and guidance? I go to, click download, gather everything I need to create a site, I can't see much asking for contributing. The Documentation top tab is better because that does ask but then again it's a bit of a "wall of a text" and people might just skip it. How can we better guide the newcomers to turn to contributors?

Moving hooks to the PHP5 era

Submitted by nk on Sun, 2010-04-11 04:30

Right now we have something like hook_user_logout which is documented in user.api.php and if mymodule wants to implement it then it needs to use a function called mymodule_user_logout. This is a Drupal convention and is not supported by any developer tool. We could instead have an interface called HookUserLogout with a single method called invoke which has the exact same signature and documentation as hook_user_logout. Edit: aside from IDE support, this would mean that PHP itself forces us to keep the hook signature. Invoking would happen through the registry table where we iterate over the classes implementing this interface. Of course, this would be cached but module_implements uses a cache in Drupal 7 already so not much change there. Code example is here, a skeleton of the invoker is here. The conversion would involve wrapping the function in a class, that's literally two lines of code including the } and renaming the function to invoke. The cost of creating a class vs calling a variable named function is not negligible but simply there are not enough on the page to make a measurable difference: 1000 calls are like 0.0025 vs 0.003 seconds.

MongoDB: what's to love (and what's not to)

Submitted by nk on Mon, 2010-03-29 18:34

Challenge: list the nodes of a user ordered by comment count. Sounds simple but the uid is stored in the node table and the comment count is in node_comment_statistics and beccause of that, this query can not be indexed and will therefore be always slow. Of course, you can begin to denormalize but do you want to keep a denormalized copy of your data for every kind of query? That's not a solution, that's a kludge and an ugly one.

To answer some trademark FUD

Submitted by nk on Sun, 2010-03-28 20:22

Somebody begun to "protest the Drupal Trademark policy [...] yet the policy requires sites, like this, to pay to use the trademarked name in various areas such as website domain names". Now, this not true. The trademark policy has been created with lots of feedback from the community and I for myself strongly support it, does allow free usage of the word Drupal if "You exclusively use the Drupal trademark to either extend or improve the Drupal software, or to encourage the use of the Drupal software (in short "foster the Drupal software"). So my blog is fine for example.

Becoming a Drupal coder: a wise career move

Submitted by nk on Sun, 2010-03-14 23:46

-- Please help getting the word out by reposting this for various programmer-but-not-Drupal lists groups etc.

Drupal 7 multistep node forms are easy

Submitted by nk on Mon, 2010-03-08 01:21

The bane of multistep node forms are validation errors. But Drupal 7 has a cure. Not nice but a cure.

Slap #access = FALSE on form elements you dont want to see in the current step and then set up the Next button with #limit_validation_errors set to the elements you are about to see. The Prev button should get an empty #limit_validation_errors. Should field validation errors bother you, you can nuke those in hook_field_attach_validate.


Multiple forms together

Submitted by nk on Sun, 2010-03-07 02:45

I have written a Drupal 7 module which allows you to put together any number of forms into one <form>. For example, if you have a professor with various titles and you have created a title entity with the various fields necessary to describe that title then you can show all the title entity forms on the user edit form in a seamless manner. Co-maintainers are welcome.

Do not use github

Submitted by nk on Thu, 2010-02-04 11:24

If you use git then use gitorious or or anything that's not github. Reasons:

  1. github source code is not available. This makes me very uncomfortable. Who knows what might happen to the source code hosted there. I am not saying they will sneak in a backdoor but they could.

User login